Photo: Bubby's

 

*Skip to the end of the page for quick summary (price, order deadline, pick-up, links)

 

🦃 Mamakoo's NYC Thanksgiving Dinner & Dessert Guide 2022

Dinners

1. Bubby's (order closed)
2. Friend of a Farmer (order closed)
3. Wayan (order by SUN 11/20)
4. Frenchette

Desserts

1. Bubby's (order closed)
2. Petee's Pie Company (delivery slots sold out, few pick-up spots available)
3. Maman (order by SUN 11/20)
4. Clinton Street Baking Co. (order by TUE 11/22 noon)
5. Little Pie Company (pre-order closed, limited pick-up available)
6. Frenchette Bakery (pre-order sold out, limited pick-up available)
7. Morgenstern's Finest Ice Cream 
8. Four & Twenty Blackbirds (BK) (pre-order sold out, limited pick-up available)
9. The Noortwyck (order by MON 11/21)

Last updated: 11/19/2022

 

Photo: Bubby's

1. Bubby's 

Did you know Bubby's opened its doors in 1990 on Thanksgiving Day? They've prepared a special dinner that tastes just like home you can simply pre-order and pick up on the Thanksgiving Day. 

The turkeys come from Pallman Farms in upstate New York and all sides, fixins and pies are made from scratch as always.

Dinner

$170 per box, each box serves 2 people and includes all the items listed. Meal is served cold with reheating instructions.

Order by: November 17, 2022
Pick up on: Thanksgiving Day, 10-4pm

• Starters: Deviled eggs, Market salad, Pickled market vegetables, Flaky buttermilk biscuits (frozen)
• Mains: Roasted Pallman Farms turkey with giblet gravy, Old fashioned glazed ham with pineapples & cherries, Add on vegetarian lasagna (gf) $15
• Sides: Cornbread stuffing, Greenbean casserole, Stoke Farms candied sweet potatoes, Roasted seasonal root vegetables, Fresh cranberry sauce, Creamy mashed potatoes
• Homemade pies (each box includes one slice of each pie): Apple whiskey crumble pie, Pumpkin pie, Sour cherry pie

Dessert (only)

Each pie serves 7-10, $45

Order by: November 18, 2022
Pick up on: Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday (November 21st-23rd)

(non-local) Shipped pies: Orders must be placed by Friday November 18th no later than 4pm EST. All Shipped pies will arrive Wednesday November 23rd.

More info: https://www.bubbys.com/thanksgiving/

 

 

 Photo: Friend of a Farmer

2. Friend of a Farmer

A pioneer of the farm-to-table movement since 1986, Friend of a Farmer is known for their use of seasonal and local ingredients, which they incorporate into hearty, country-style dishes. 

Place your Thanksgiving to-go orders online or by telephone, 212-477-2188 or email, gramercy@friendofafarmer.com.

Dinner

Order by: November 17, 2022
Pick up on: Thanksgiving Day, 9AM & 12PM

• Start With: Creamy Corn Chowder served with cornbread & apple butter
• Enjoy: Harvest CrostiniRoasted butternut squash, whipped honey & feta cheese, fig chutney, sage, cracked sea salt
• Traditional Thanksgiving Fixings (choose one): Oven Roasted Turkey, Honey Glazed Ham, Salmon
• served with gravy, cornbread stuffing, cranberries, creamy mashed potatoes & maple sweet potatoes, family style traditional succotash
• Famous Deep Dish Pies: Granny Smith Apple with vanilla ice cream

More info: https://www.friendofafarmer.com/shop/p/thanksgiving-day-feast 

 

 

Photo: Wayan

3. Wayan

Looking for something different this year? For a twist of traditional, Cedric and Ochi Vongerichten’s Wayan will be offering prepared family-style Thanksgiving meals with a menu of Indonesian-inspired classics.

Wayan’s holiday feast includes organic roasted turkey breast and a medley of sides with brussels sprouts with morning glory terasi, perkedel stuffing, mashed potatoes, roasted delicata squash topped with ginger-coconut crust, spiced cranberry acar sauce and long pepper gravy.

Dinner

Order by: November 20, 2022
Pick up on: November 23-24, 2022 (Wednesday)
Delivery: Manhattan with additional cost of $20 and $35 for Brooklyn or Queens.

Each set serves 2-4 for $228 or 6-8 for $448 with heating and serving instructions to prepare on the day-of. Optional add-ons include homemade ube pie ($68/ea) and cocktail mixers.

• Roasted Turkey, Perkedel Stuffing, Brussel Sprouts Terrasi, Sweet Potato, Delicata Squash, Black Pepper Gravy, Cranberry Acar

More info: https://wayan-home.com/

 

 

Photo: Petee's Pie Company

4. Petee's Pie Company

Leave the pie job for the pie experts. One of Mamakoo editors' favorites in NYC, Petee's Pie started Thanksgiving pre-order offering 19 kinds of pies including gluten-free & vegan pies for everyone!

Desserts

They offer smaller 6" size pies for cozy gatherings as well as their regular whole pies. 

From classic Hudson Valley Apple to one-of-a-kind Pear Streusel, Petee's offer one of the best locally-sourced, made-from-scratch pies in NYC. 

Source: Petee's Pie Company

 

Order by: November 20, 2022 (Order ASAP to avoid sold-out) 
*After that, pies will be available at both locations on a first come first served basis. 
Pick up on: November 23-24, 2022 (Wednesday)
Delivery: November 21-22, 2022

More info: https://thanksgiving.peteespie.com/

 

 

  Photo: Clinton St. Baking Company

5. Clinton St. Baking Company

Lower East Side's classic, unassuming American breakfast & brunch spot, Clinton St. Baking Company is now accepting Thanksgiving pie pre-orders for pick up.

Clinton St. Baking Company is known to serve an eclectic menu inspired from the American South, coastal New England, Jewish New York, and the Spanish cooks who bring to the kitchen their rich culinary traditions from Mexico and the Southwest!

Desserts

• Regular Pumpkin Butterscotch Pie (Serves 6-8) —$29.00
• Mini Pumpkin Butterscotch Pie (Serves 2-3) —$16.00
• Regular Organic Apple Crumb Pie—Nut Free (Serves 6-8) —$30.00
• Mini Organic Apple Crumb Pie—Nut Free (Serves 2-3) —$17.00
• Regular Maple Bourbon Pecan Pie (Serves 6-8) —$32.00
• Mini Maple Bourbon Pecan Pie (Serves 2-3) —$18.00

Add-ons

• 1 Dozen Mini Buttermilk Biscuits —$14.00
• 2 Dozen Mini Buttermilk Biscuits —$26.00
• 3 Dozen Mini Buttermilk Biscuits —$36.00
• Raspberry Jam (pint) —$8.00

Order by: November 22, 2022 12PM
Pick up on: November 23, 2022 (Wednesday) 9AM - 8PM* 
*Manhattan pickup only at the Lower East Side location.

More info: https://clintonstreetbaking.com/thanksgiving

Photo: Maman

6. Maman

Inspired by childhood memories in the South of France, Maman recreates the feeling of home through wholesome plates and buttery baked goods.

Desserts

Each 9" pie serves 8-10 - $42

• Spiced apple crumb
• Mixed berry
• Pumpkin with mascarpone
• Classic pecan

Add-ons

Insider tip: You can also add your Maman favorites like pastries, quiche, salad, platters (salmon, cheese, charcuterie, crudite), coffee and more to complete the entire day! Breakfast & brunch, party platters and desserts all taken care of in one place.

 

Order by: November 20, 2022
Pick up on: November 17-23, 2022
*Manhattan pickup only at the Lower East Side location.

More info: https://catering.mamannyc.com/menu

 

 
Photo: Little Pie Company

7. Little Pie Company

What if you want to get them all? No need to choose only one with Little Pie Company, because these mindful people offer Thanksgiving pie sampler for us oinksters! They offer four 5-inch miniature versions of their most popular pies including Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie (to die for), Southern Pecan Pie, Mississippi Mud Pie and Pumpkin Pie.

Little Pie Company offers pick-up, delivery and nationwide shipping.

Desserts

$42-48/pie, serves 8-10

• Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie
• Old Fashioned Apple Pie
• Sugarless Old Fashioned Apple Pie
• No sugar or artificial sweeteners
• Southern Pecan Pie
• Mississippi Mud Pie
• Three Berry Pie
• Pumpkin Pie
• * Sweet Potato Pie
• * Salted Caramel Apple Pie
• * Gluten Free Florida Key Lime Pie
• * Gluten Free Blueberry Apple Crumb Pie

* Very limited quantities available. Order early!

Store hours for Thanksgiving week

November 21-22 (Mon-Tue): 8AM - 8PM.
November 23 (Wed): 8AM - 9PM
November 24 (Thanksgiving Day) 8AM - 12PM

Order by: November 16, 2022
Pick up by: November 24, 2022 12PM

More info: https://www.littlepiecompany.com/ 

 

 

Photo: Frenchette Bakery

8. Frenchette Bakery

Since their opening in Fall 2020, locals in the knows have been lining up to pick up their boulangerie offerings every morning before they're sold out in the afternoon. For this Thanksgiving, skip the line and pre-order one (or more) of their classic pie offerings for pick-up!

Desserts

• 10" Thanksgiving Pies (Apple, Pumpkin, Pecan) - $60

Order by: November 18, 2022 (can be sold out before, order ASAP)
Pick up by: November 21-24, 2022

More info: https://www.frenchettebakery.com/thanksgiving/thanksgiving-pies

 

 

Photo: Morgenstern's Finest Ice Cream

9. Morgenstern's Finest Ice Cream

Perfect pairing with your Thanksgiving pies? 🍨 Ice creams! You can conveniently order the pie-ice cream pairs from Morgenstern's with their 54 ice cream flavors and make it à la mode!

Desserts

Each pie serves 8-10

• Pork Lard Apple Pie - $42
• Pumpkin Pie with Sweet Butter Crust - $42
• Pecan Pie with Sweet Butter Crust - $42
• Bourbon Pecan Pie with Chocolate Crust - $42
• Pie à la Mode Pack - $68
• Burnt Sage Ice Cream Pie - $52
• Peanut Butter Chocolate Ice Cream Pie - $52
• Lemon Meringue Ice Cream Pie - $52

All pies require 48 hours notice prior to pick-up.

Order by: November 21, 2022
Pick up by: November 21-24, 2022

More info: https://www.morgensternsnyc.com/collections/nyc-pies

 

Photo: Four & Twenty Blackbirds 

10. Four & Twenty Blackbirds

This Brooklyn's obligatory pie spot is accepting pre-orders for your Thanksgiving pies for pick-up and a limited number of delivery slots.

Their annual Thanksgiving pie flavors are:

• Salted Caramel Apple
• Brown Butter Pumpkin
• Bittersweet Chocolate
• Pecan and Salty Honey

Each 10" pie serves 8-10 - $44

Order by: November 21, 2022 (limited quantity)
Pick up by: November 19-24, 2022 at 2 locations
Limited delivery available (not on Thanksgiving Day)

More info: https://birdsblack.com/collections/thanksgiving

Thanksgiving FAQ: https://birdsblack.com/pages/copy-of-faq

 

Photo: The Noortwyck

11. The Noortwyck

Meaning ''North District” in Dutch, The Noortwyck is one of the newest seasonal American restaurants in the city. Helmed by Eleven Madison Park alumni duo Chef Andrew Quinn and Sommelier Cedric Nicaise, their new spot in the East Village focuses on incorporating locally sourced products into their elevated seasonal à la carte menu.

Their pastry chef is baking 3 different classic pies:

• Apple Streusel Pie
• Bourbon Brown Butter Pecan Pie
• Pumpkin Pie

Each pie serves 8 - $65

Order by: November 16, 2022 (limited quantity)
Pick up by: November 23-24, 2022

More info: https://resy.com/cities/ny/venues/the-noortwyck/events/the-noortwyck-pie-sale-2022-11-23

 

Photo: Frenchette

12. Frenchette

Run by Riad Nasr and Lee Hanson, Frenchette is a trendy French-inspired bistro located in Tribeca, no less. If you manage to secure a reservation at a reasonable time, you’re sure to be dining in the company of some of New York’s most illustrious – it’s that popular. Their menu is reminiscent of a classic French brasserie, and you can enjoy their elevated, fully-prepared Thanksgiving meal at home.

Dinner

$700 per box, serves 4-6 people and includes all the items listed. Meal is served cold with reheating instructions.

• Pate en croute: heritage pork, pistachio, koginut squash
• Pumpkin Soup
• Salade de chicoree: radicchio, Castelfranco, Treviso, Banyuls vinaigrette
• Pull-apart parker house rolls: rosemary, sea salt
• Heritage Turkey : Good Shepherd Ranch, soy glaze
• Rick's brussels sprouts / Chestnut stuffing / Pomme puree / Roasted carrots & parsnips / Turkey giblet gravy / Cranberry preserves
• Pumpkin pie: crème fraiche Chantilly
  
  

 

Order by: not specified
Pick up by: November 23-24, 2022

More info: https://www.frenchettenyc.com/

Summary

1. Bubby's

• Dinner: $170 per box, each box serves 2
  Order by: November 17, 2022
  Pick up on: Thanksgiving Day, 10-4pm
• Dessert (pies): $45, serves 7-10
  Order by: November 18, 2022
  Pick up on: Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday (November 21st-23rd)
• More info: https://www.bubbys.com/thanksgiving/

2. Friend of a Farmer

• Dinner: $77.30/person
  Order by: November 17, 2022
  Pick up on: Thanksgiving Day, 9AM & 12PM
• More info: https://www.friendofafarmer.com/shop/p/thanksgiving-day-feast 

3. Wayan

• Dinner: $228 for 2-4 servings, $448 for 6-8 servings
  Order by: November 20, 2022
  Pick up on: November 23-24, 2022 (Wednesday)
  Delivery: Manhattan with additional cost of $20 and $35 for Brooklyn or Queens
• More info: https://wayan-home.com/

4. Petee's Pie Company

• Pies: $35-40 for regular, $15 for 6" (smaller)
  Order by: November 20, 2022 (limited quantity)
  *After that, pies will be available at both locations on a first come first served basis.
  Pick up on: November 23-24, 2022 (Wednesday)
  Delivery: November 21-22, 2022

• More info: https://thanksgiving.peteespie.com/

5. Clinton Street Baking Co.

• Pies: $29-32 for 6-8 servings, $16-18 for 2-3 servings
  Order by: November 22, 2022 12PM
  Pick up on: November 23, 2022 (Wednesday) 9AM - 8PM*
  *Manhattan pickup only at the Lower East Side location.
• More info: https://clintonstreetbaking.com/thanksgiving

6. Maman

• Pies: $42 (Each 9" pie serves 8-10)
  Order by: November 20, 2022
  Pick up on: November 17-23, 2022
• Add-ons available: coffee, platters, sandwiches, pastries, quiche
• More info: https://catering.mamannyc.com/menu

7. Little Pie Company

• Pies: $42-48, serves 8-10
  Order by: November 16, 2022
  Pick up by: November 24, 2022 12PM
• More info: https://www.littlepiecompany.com/ 

8. Frenchette Bakery

• Pies: $60, 10" - serves 10
  Order by: November 18, 2022 (can be sold out before, order ASAP)
  Pick up by: November 21-24, 2022
• More info: https://www.frenchettebakery.com/thanksgiving/thanksgiving-pies

9. Morgenstern's Finest Ice Cream

• Pies: $42-52, serves 8-10
  Pie & Ice Cream (Pie à la Mode Pack): $68
  Order by: November 21, 2022
  Pick up by: November 21-24, 2022
• More info: https://www.morgensternsnyc.com/collections/nyc-pies

10. Four & Twenty Blackbirds (BK)

• Pies: $44, 10" serves 8-10
  Order by: November 21, 2022 (limited quantity)
  Pick up by: November 19-24, 2022 at 2 locations
  Limited delivery available (not on Thanksgiving Day)
• More info: https://birdsblack.com/collections/thanksgiving
• Thanksgiving FAQ: https://birdsblack.com/pages/copy-of-faq

11. The Noortwyck

• Pies: $65, serves 8
  Order by: November 16, 2022 (limited quantity)
  Pick up by: November 23-24, 2022
• More info: https://resy.com/cities/ny/venues/the-noortwyck/events/the-noortwyck-pie-sale-2022-11-23

12. Frenchette

• Dinner: $700, serves 4-6
  Pick up by: November 23-24, 2022
• More info: https://www.frenchettenyc.com/

 --

We'll keep updating this list until Thanksgiving Day :)

Traveling for the holidays? Check out our food guides in destinations around the world. See Mamakoo destinations

Happy eating, and happy Thanksgiving! 🦃🧡